For gardeners seeking the best lily bulbs, my best overall pick is the BRECK’S All Summer Lily Mixture, which offers the largest listed count for planting a varied display. For a smaller, more focused planting, Easy to Grow Oriental Lily Mix stands out for its 12-bulb assortment, while Blacklist Asiatic Lily suits buyers drawn to deep burgundy blooms. The main tradeoffs are variety versus color control, larger packs versus small trial plantings, and choosing genuine dormant bulbs rather than artificial flowers. I compare all 13 options by type, stated pack size, and likely buyer fit below. Read on for the full breakdown and help choosing the right option for your space.
Get garden gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- BRECK’S All Summer Lily Mixture has the largest stated count at 25 dormant bulbs, making it the standout for filling a bed, though a mixed assortment offers less control over the final color layout.
- Easy to Grow Oriental Lily Mix pairs a 12-bulb count with an Oriental assortment, a stronger fit for gardeners who want a sizable planting centered on that lily type.
- Small packs work better for focused color choices or trial plantings: the Ducati Red has two bulbs, while Stargazer, Dark Secret, and several other selections list three.
- Asiatic and Oriental options serve different display goals; the lineup includes vivid Asiatic colors and mixes alongside Oriental selections such as Stargazer and the Oriental mixes.
- Two listings are artificial flowers, not bulbs: Giant Hybrid Lily Empoli and Asiatic Lily Rapid Yellow are decorative alternatives and will not grow or flower in a garden.
| Giant Hybrid Lily Empoli Artificial Flowers, 4-Pack | ![]() | Best Artificial Display | Product type: Artificial flowers | Quantity: 4 flowers | Material: Polyester | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Giant Pretty Lady Tree Lily Bulbs, White Blooms, 3-Pack | ![]() | Best for Dramatic Height | Plant type: Lily | Pack size: 3 bulbs | Bloom color: White | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| CZ Grain Lollipop Asiatic Lily Bulbs, Pink and White Bicolor, 3 Bulbs | ![]() | Best for Beds and Containers | Plant type: Asiatic lily | Variety: Lollipop | Quantity: 3 bulbs | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Easy to Grow ‘Dark Secret’ Asiatic Lily Bulbs, 3 Pack | ![]() | Best for Dark Blooms | Plant type: Asiatic lily hybrid | Quantity: 3 bulbs | Flower color: Dark maroon | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 3 Large Pink Stargazer Lily Bulbs | ![]() | Best Fragrant Oriental Pick | Plant type: Oriental lily | Quantity: 3 bulbs | Color: Pink | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Blacklist Asiatic Lily Bulbs, Deep Burgundy Nearly Black Flowers, 3 Bulbs | ![]() | Best for Dramatic Dark Blooms | Bulb count: 3 | Flower color: Deep burgundy to nearly black | Blooming period: Summer to winter (as listed) | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| All Summer Blooms Asiatic Lily Bulbs, Mixed Colors, 10 Pack | ![]() | Best Value for a Colorful Asiatic Display | Quantity: 10 bulbs | Flower colors: Red, yellow, orange, and pink | Expected bloom period: Summer | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| BRECK’S All Summer Lily Mixture Dormant Bulbs, 25 Count | ![]() | Best for a Long, Varied Summer Display | Quantity: 25 dormant bulbs | Lily varieties: Oriental, tiger, Asiatic, trumpet, and species | Bloom period: Early to late summer, depending on variety | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Easy to Grow Oriental Lily Mix Bulbs, 12 Count | ![]() | Best for Fragrant Oriental Blooms | Quantity: 12 bulbs | Lily type: Oriental | Flower colors: Pink, maroon, and white | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Asiatic Lily Rapid Yellow Artificial Flowers, 4-Pack | ![]() | Best No-Maintenance Lily Look | Product type: Artificial flower | Set quantity: 4 arrangements | Flower count: 6 | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Oriental Stargazer Lily Bulbs, 4-Pack | ![]() | Best for Coordinated Stargazer Plantings | Plant type: Oriental lily | Variety: Stargazer | Quantity: 4 bulbs | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Votaniki Ducati Red Asiatic Lily Bulbs, 2 Pack | ![]() | Best for Compact Red Lily Displays | Plant type: Asiatic lily | Pack size: 2 bulbs | Color: Red | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Votaniki Oriental Lily Mix Bulbs, 3 Pack | ![]() | Best for Fragrant, Tall Garden Backdrops | Plant type: Oriental lilies | Pack size: 3 bulbs | Bloom colors: Pink, red, white, and yellow | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| lily bulb | Quantity | Plant type |
|---|---|---|
| Giant Hybrid Lily Empoli Artif | 4 flowers | — |
| Giant Pretty Lady Tree Lily Bu | — | Lily |
| CZ Grain Lollipop Asiatic Lily | 3 bulbs | Asiatic lily |
| Easy to Grow ‘Dark Secret’ Asi | 3 bulbs | Asiatic lily hybrid |
| 3 Large Pink Stargazer Lily Bu | 3 bulbs | Oriental lily |
| Blacklist Asiatic Lily Bulbs | — | — |
| All Summer Blooms Asiatic Lily | 10 bulbs | — |
| BRECK’S All Summer Lily Mixtur | 25 dormant bulbs | — |
| Easy to Grow Oriental Lily Mix | 12 bulbs | — |
| Asiatic Lily Rapid Yellow Arti | — | — |
| Oriental Stargazer Lily Bulbs | 4 bulbs | Oriental lily |
| Votaniki Ducati Red Asiatic Li | — | Asiatic lily |
| Votaniki Oriental Lily Mix Bul | — | Oriental lilies |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Giant Hybrid Lily Empoli Artificial Flowers, 4-Pack
This is the outlier in a roundup of lily bulbs: it is a set of four finished artificial flowers, not bulbs to plant. That makes it useful for someone who wants a coordinated lily-style display without waiting for summer blooms or managing watering. The polyester flowers are unscented, a practical choice for scent-sensitive rooms, and the listing describes them as UV resistant. Compared with the living Dark Secret Asiatic Lily Bulbs, this set offers immediate, low-maintenance color but cannot grow, flower seasonally, or attract pollinators. There is a clear mismatch in the product details: it is listed for indoor use despite the UV-resistance claim, so I would not treat it as a dependable outdoor option. Choose it only if artificial flowers meet your goal.
Pros:- Four flowers support a coordinated display
- Unscented, which may suit scent-sensitive rooms
- Polyester construction is listed as UV resistant
- Includes a plastic rectangular container
Cons:- Artificial flowers do not grow, rebloom, or attract pollinators
- Product is listed for indoor use despite its UV-resistance claim
- The listing’s artificial-flower format conflicts with a lily-bulb buying goal
Best for: Shoppers who want a ready-made, unscented indoor lily display and do not need living bulbs or seasonal blooms
Not ideal for: Gardeners seeking plantable bulbs, fragrant flowers, or a product clearly suited to outdoor display
- Product type:Artificial flowers
- Quantity:4 flowers
- Material:Polyester
- Container:Plastic, rectangular
- Dimensions:6 × 8 × 12 inches
- Flower count:6
- Scent:Unscented
- UV resistance:Listed as UV resistant
- Intended use:Indoor
Our verdict“Pick this only for a ready-to-display indoor arrangement; gardeners should choose a living option such as Dark Secret instead.”
Giant Pretty Lady Tree Lily Bulbs, White Blooms, 3-Pack
These bulbs are for gardeners who want lilies to command attention above shorter border plants. The listing describes plants reaching up to 8 feet, with white flowers around 8 inches wide and more than 30 blooms per plant—a much taller, fuller effect than the 24–36-inch Lollipop Asiatic lilies. Their reported fragrance and pollinator appeal add garden presence beyond their height, while perennial growth can bring flowers back in suitable conditions. The tradeoff is that a plant this tall needs a site where it has room and support; it is not the easy fit for a compact container or exposed spot. It also calls for partial shade, moderate watering, and sandy soil, so buyers with different garden conditions should check the planting fit before choosing this over the more compact Asiatic options.
Pros:- Plants are listed as reaching up to 8 feet
- Large white blooms are described as about 8 inches wide
- Listing reports more than 30 blooms per plant
- Perennial, fragrant, and described as attractive to pollinators
Cons:- Exceptional height can make placement and support more demanding
- Calls for partial shade, moderate watering, and sandy soil
- Three bulbs may be less suitable for gardeners seeking a broad mass planting
Best for: Gardeners with room for tall, showy perennial lilies who want fragrant white blooms and a strong vertical focal point
Not ideal for: Small-space or container gardeners, and growers whose beds lack partial shade or suitable sandy soil
- Plant type:Lily
- Pack size:3 bulbs
- Bloom color:White
- Expected height:Up to 8 feet
- Bloom size:About 8 inches
- Blooms per plant:Over 30
- Blooming period:Summer
- Sunlight exposure:Partial shade
- Hardiness zones:USDA 3–11
Our verdict“Choose this three-bulb pack for a spacious garden where height, fragrance, and abundant white flowers matter more than compact growth.”
CZ Grain Lollipop Asiatic Lily Bulbs, Pink and White Bicolor, 3 Bulbs
The Lollipop Asiatic earns its place for compact versatility: at 24–36 inches, it fits borders and patio containers more readily than the 8-foot Pretty Lady Tree Lily. Its pink-tipped white flowers bring a two-color look without the deep maroon palette of Dark Secret, and the blooms can also be cut for arrangements. Full sun to partial shade gives gardeners more placement flexibility than Dark Secret’s full-sun requirement. The main limitation is seasonal: this is an early- to mid-summer bloomer, not a source of flowers year-round or across the whole growing season. It also needs well-drained soil, so heavy, persistently wet beds are a poor match. I’d choose it when manageable height and a bicolor display matter more than fragrance or extra-tall stems.
Pros:- Pink-and-white flowers offer a distinct bicolor look
- 24–36-inch height suits borders and many containers
- Can be grown in full sun or partial shade
- Flowers work in cut arrangements and attract pollinators
Cons:- Requires well-drained soil
- Blooming is limited to early to mid-summer
- Three bulbs provide a smaller planting than larger mixed packs
Best for: Gardeners wanting medium-height, bicolor lilies for a sunny border, patio container, or cut-flower garden
Not ideal for: Growers with poorly drained beds or those seeking fragrant flowers, very tall stems, or blooms beyond early to mid-summer
- Plant type:Asiatic lily
- Variety:Lollipop
- Quantity:3 bulbs
- Flower color:Pink and white bicolor
- Bloom time:Early to mid-summer
- Mature height:24–36 inches
- Sun exposure:Full sun to partial shade
- Hardiness zones:USDA 3–8
- Soil:Well-drained
Our verdict“Choose Lollipop for a flexible, medium-height bicolor planting, especially where Dark Secret’s full-sun preference or dark blooms are less suitable.”
Easy to Grow ‘Dark Secret’ Asiatic Lily Bulbs, 3 Pack
Dark maroon flowers give Dark Secret a distinct role among these living bulbs: it is the color-led choice for gardeners who want a dramatic contrast rather than the white Pretty Lady or pink-and-white Lollipop. At about 3 feet tall, it remains easier to place in a standard bed than the tree lily, and its low fragrance may suit people who prefer less scent. The flowers can also be cut for indoor arrangements. This pack is less flexible about site than Lollipop, though: Dark Secret calls for full sun, moderate watering, and amended soil. The product notes that images are for reference, so the exact bloom appearance may vary. Choose it for its dark early-summer color, not for a highly fragrant or shade-tolerant lily.
Pros:- Dark maroon blooms provide a distinctive color contrast
- About 3 feet tall, making it less imposing than the Pretty Lady Tree Lily
- Low fragrance may suit scent-sensitive gardeners
- Flowers can be cut for arrangements
Cons:- Requires full sun, unlike the partial-shade-tolerant Lollipop
- Needs moderate watering and amended soil
- Listing says flower appearance may differ from reference images
Best for: Gardeners who want dark maroon early-summer blooms for a sunny bed or cut-flower arrangements, especially if strong fragrance is unwelcome
Not ideal for: Gardeners with shaded planting sites, or buyers who want fragrant flowers or an exact match to listing images
- Plant type:Asiatic lily hybrid
- Quantity:3 bulbs
- Flower color:Dark maroon
- Expected height:About 3 feet
- Bloom season:Early summer
- Sunlight exposure:Full sun
- Planting period:Fall to spring
- Hardiness zones:USDA 4–9
- Soil and moisture:Amended soil; moderate watering
Our verdict“Pick Dark Secret for dark, low-fragrance blooms in a sunny garden; choose Lollipop instead if you need more shade flexibility.”
3 Large Pink Stargazer Lily Bulbs
For buyers who want fragrance as well as pink flowers, these Stargazer bulbs fill a different niche from the low-fragrance Dark Secret and the unscented artificial Empoli display. The Oriental lilies grow to about 3 feet, making them a more manageable option than the towering Pretty Lady Tree Lily, while their perennial habit suits a garden or container planting intended to return in suitable conditions. Their part-to-full-sun preference gives some flexibility, though they still need moderate watering and a reasonably sunny spot. The listing does not give a bloom season or flower dimensions, so I would not choose this pack when timing or exact flower scale is central to the plan. It makes the most sense when pink color and fragrance take priority over those missing details.
Pros:- Fragrant pink flowers offer a scented alternative to Dark Secret
- Perennial Oriental lily suitable for gardens or containers
- Height of up to 3 feet is easier to place than the 8-foot Pretty Lady
- Listed for a broad range of USDA zones
Cons:- Requires part to full sun
- Needs moderate watering
- Listing does not specify bloom time or flower size
Best for: Gardeners who prioritize fragrant pink perennial lilies for a sunny garden bed or container and can provide moderate watering
Not ideal for: Buyers who need stated bloom timing or flower dimensions, or gardeners who want low-fragrance blooms for a scent-sensitive space
- Plant type:Oriental lily
- Quantity:3 bulbs
- Color:Pink
- Expected height:Up to 3 feet
- Sunlight:Part to full sun
- Hardiness zones:USDA 3–9
- Moisture needs:Moderate watering
- Use:Garden or container
- Flower scent:Fragrant
Our verdict“Choose Stargazer when fragrant pink blooms matter more than having a stated bloom schedule or exact flower dimensions.”
Blacklist Asiatic Lily Bulbs, Deep Burgundy Nearly Black Flowers, 3 Bulbs
Blacklist is the standout pick for near-black color: its deep burgundy, wine-red blooms bring a darker look than the red, yellow, orange, and pink mix in All Summer Blooms. Large, upward-facing flowers and strong stems also make these bulbs a useful choice for cutting, not just for adding contrast to a sunny border. They suit beds, borders, and containers, giving gardeners more placement options than a narrowly specified planting. The tradeoff is the small three-bulb count, which makes a concentrated display easier than filling a large area. These lilies also call for full sun, well-draining soil, and regular watering; gardeners with shaded or poorly drained sites should choose a different planting plan. The listed blooming period is unusual for a lily, so I would treat summer as the more dependable expectation.
Pros:- Deep burgundy blooms with nearly black centers create strong contrast against green foliage.
- Large, upward-facing flowers are visible in beds and containers.
- Strong stems and rich color make the blooms suitable for cut arrangements.
- Can be planted in beds, borders, containers, or cutting gardens.
Cons:- Three bulbs are better suited to a small accent than a broad display.
- Requires full sun and well-draining soil.
- Regular watering is needed to support growth.
Best for: Gardeners with a sunny, well-drained bed or container who want a small focal planting of unusually dark lilies and flowers for cutting.
Not ideal for: Buyers filling a large border on a tight bulb count, or gardeners whose planting site is shaded or stays wet.
- Bulb count:3
- Flower color:Deep burgundy to nearly black
- Blooming period:Summer to winter (as listed)
- Sunlight:Full sun
- USDA hardiness zones:4–8
- Soil type:Loam
- Soil moisture:Moderate watering
- Item weight:2 pounds
Our verdict“Choose Blacklist for a sunny spot where a few near-black, cut-worthy blooms matter more than planting a large area.”
All Summer Blooms Asiatic Lily Bulbs, Mixed Colors, 10 Pack
This ten-bulb Asiatic mix is the practical choice for a broader, multicolor planting. Red, yellow, orange, and pink flowers offer more variety across a bed than Blacklist’s three-bulb, near-black accent, while its Asiatic-only mix gives the display a more consistent style than BRECK’S All Summer Lily Mixture, which combines five lily types. The flowers are described as large and suitable for cutting, and the mix can attract pollinators. With proper care, bulbs may return and multiply, adding potential for a longer-lived planting. The tradeoff is that color placement is less controlled in a mix, and the plants need room: the listed spacing is 4 to 6 inches, with tall growth. Full sun, well-drained soil, and regular watering are also part of the care commitment, so this is not a set-and-forget option.
Pros:- Ten bulbs support a fuller planting than the three-bulb Blacklist option.
- Red, yellow, orange, and pink flowers add a varied color mix.
- Large blooms are suitable for cutting and can attract pollinators.
- May return and multiply with proper care.
Cons:- Mixed colors offer less control over the final color layout.
- Tall growth and 4-to-6-inch spacing require room in the garden.
- Needs full sun, well-drained soil, and regular watering.
Best for: Gardeners planting a sunny border or cutting patch who want several bright Asiatic lily colors and enough bulbs for a more substantial display.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want one precise flower color, have limited planting space, or cannot provide regular watering and well-drained soil.
- Quantity:10 bulbs
- Flower colors:Red, yellow, orange, and pink
- Expected bloom period:Summer
- Planting period:Spring
- Sunlight:Full sun
- USDA hardiness zones:3–8
- Planting depth:6–8 inches
- Spacing:4–6 inches
- Soil and moisture:Well-drained soil; regular watering
Our verdict“Pick this mix for a sunny garden or cutting patch where multiple bright colors and a ten-bulb planting matter more than exact color control.”
BRECK’S All Summer Lily Mixture Dormant Bulbs, 25 Count
BRECK’S offers the broadest lily variety in this group: its 25 dormant bulbs mix Oriental, tiger, Asiatic, trumpet, and species lilies, with different flower shapes, colors, and bloom times. The varieties are described as flowering from early to late summer, making this a stronger fit for a changing seasonal display than the single-style All Summer Blooms Asiatic mix. Its larger count also suits gardeners planning a substantial bed rather than a small accent like Blacklist. Mature heights of 24 to 48 inches make the planting visible, but demand more space and thoughtful placement. The tradeoff is less uniformity: a mixed-species collection will not deliver the consistent look of an Asiatic-only planting. It needs full sun and regular watering, though it can tolerate heavier soils when they drain well.
Pros:- Twenty-five bulbs can fill a larger planting than the smaller mixes in this lineup.
- Five lily types bring varied flower shapes and colors.
- Different varieties can bloom from early to late summer.
- Tolerates heavier soils when the planting site drains well.
Cons:- The mixed varieties may produce a less uniform-looking bed than an Asiatic-only pack.
- Bulbs need 8 to 12 inches of spacing, taking more garden area.
- Full sun and regular watering are required.
Best for: Gardeners with a roomy, sunny bed who want multiple lily types, varied flower forms, and bloom timing spread across summer.
Not ideal for: Gardeners seeking a uniform cultivar or a compact container planting, or anyone without room for bulbs spaced 8 to 12 inches apart.
- Quantity:25 dormant bulbs
- Lily varieties:Oriental, tiger, Asiatic, trumpet, and species
- Bloom period:Early to late summer, depending on variety
- Mature height:24–48 inches
- Plant spacing:8–12 inches
- Sun exposure:Full sun
- Soil:Sandy soil; well-drained, tolerates heavier soils
- Watering:Regular
Our verdict“Choose BRECK’S for a spacious sunny garden where variety and a longer sequence of summer blooms outweigh a uniform look.”
Easy to Grow Oriental Lily Mix Bulbs, 12 Count
For fragrance, this Oriental mix fills a different role from the Asiatic options: its 12 bulbs produce pink, maroon, and white blooms described as fragrant, while All Summer Blooms emphasizes bright Asiatic colors and pollinator appeal. That makes this pack a natural fit for gardeners who want cut flowers with scent as well as color. Indoor and outdoor use offers more flexibility than BRECK’S 25-bulb garden-focused mixture, though the product details do not specify container dimensions or indoor growing conditions. Its 12-bulb count is substantial without requiring the space of the larger BRECK’S collection. The tradeoffs are full-sun placement and moderate watering, plus some uncertainty around exact flower appearance: the listing says images are for reference only. It is also limited to zones 5–9, narrower than the hardy All Summer Blooms mix.
Pros:- Fragrant blooms distinguish this Oriental mix from the Asiatic selections.
- Pink, maroon, and white flowers provide several color options.
- Blooms can be used in fragrant cut arrangements.
- Listed for indoor and outdoor use.
Cons:- Hardiness is limited to USDA zones 5–9.
- Full sun and moderate watering are required.
- Flower images are for reference only, so exact appearance may vary.
Best for: Gardeners in zones 5–9 who want fragrant pink, maroon, and white lilies for sunny beds or cut arrangements, with indoor use as an option.
Not ideal for: Buyers in colder zones outside 5–9, those who need a reliably specified flower appearance, or gardeners unable to provide full sun.
- Quantity:12 bulbs
- Lily type:Oriental
- Flower colors:Pink, maroon, and white
- Blooming period:Spring to summer
- Planting period:Fall to spring
- Sunlight:Full sun
- USDA hardiness zones:5–9
- Soil and watering:Amended soil; moderate watering
- Use:Indoor and outdoor
Our verdict“Choose this Oriental mix if fragrance and cut flowers are priorities and your growing conditions fit zones 5–9.”
Asiatic Lily Rapid Yellow Artificial Flowers, 4-Pack
This is not a lily bulb purchase: it is a four-piece set of artificial yellow Asiatic lily arrangements, so it belongs only on a roundup shortlist for shoppers who want lily-inspired decor without gardening. Unlike the living bulbs in All Summer Blooms, these flowers do not depend on sun, soil, or watering, and their UV-resistant polyester is intended for indoor or outdoor display. The set includes plastic rectangular containers, making it ready to group as decor rather than a planting project. That convenience comes with a clear compromise: no living growth, seasonal bloom, or fragrance. The flowers are unscented, and the plastic containers may not suit more natural-looking displays. Compared with the real fragrant blooms of Easy to Grow Oriental Lily Mix, this is a decor solution, not an alternative for gardeners seeking cut flowers from their own plants.
Pros:- UV-resistant polyester is intended for indoor or outdoor display.
- Unscented flowers suit spaces where floral fragrance is unwanted.
- Four arrangements can be grouped for a coordinated display.
- Includes rectangular plastic containers.
Cons:- Artificial flowers do not grow, bloom seasonally, or attract pollinators.
- Unscented material cannot provide the fragrance of live Oriental lilies.
- Plastic containers may not fit naturalistic or premium decor styles.
Best for: Home decorators who want grouped yellow lily-style displays for indoor or outdoor spaces without planting or watering.
Not ideal for: Anyone specifically shopping for live lily bulbs, fragrant flowers, pollinator-friendly planting, or a natural garden display.
- Product type:Artificial flower
- Set quantity:4 arrangements
- Flower count:6
- Color:Yellow
- Materials:Polyester flowers; plastic containers
- Dimensions:6 × 8 × 12 inches
- UV resistant:Yes
- Scent:Unscented
- Indoor/outdoor use:Indoor and outdoor
Our verdict“Buy this only if you want low-maintenance yellow lily-style decor; choose a live bulb pack for real growth and flowers.”
Oriental Stargazer Lily Bulbs, 4-Pack
Four bulbs of one named variety make this a practical choice for a matching border section, a group of containers, or a small cut-flower patch. The listing describes fragrant Oriental blooms and gives several planting uses, but it does not specify flower color, mature height, bloom timing, or care instructions. That leaves more uncertainty than with Votaniki’s Oriental Lily Mix, which lists colors and growing details, though its mixed varieties suit gardeners seeking a less uniform display. Compared with the two-bulb Ducati Red Asiatic lilies, this pack offers more bulbs and a scented Oriental type, but not the same clear hardiness and planting guidance. Choose it when the Stargazer name and coordinated planting matter more than detailed growing specifications; skip it if you need color or care information before ordering.
Pros:- Four bulbs support a grouped planting rather than a single focal plant.
- Fragrant Oriental lily blooms suit garden displays and cut arrangements.
- The listed uses include borders, containers, and grouped plantings.
Cons:- Bloom color is not specified, making the finished display hard to plan.
- Planting and care requirements are not provided.
- Height and blooming period are also absent from the supplied details.
Best for: Gardeners seeking four bulbs of one fragrant Oriental lily variety for a coordinated border, containers, or cut-flower planting.
Not ideal for: New lily growers who need clear planting and care directions, or buyers who must know the bloom color before choosing.
- Plant type:Oriental lily
- Variety:Stargazer
- Quantity:4 bulbs
- Item weight:8 ounces
- Item dimensions:6 x 8 x 12 inches
- Container type:Box
- Special feature:UV resistant
Our verdict“Choose this four-pack for a coordinated planting of fragrant Stargazer lilies, but pick the Votaniki Oriental Lily Mix if you need clearer color and growing information.”
Votaniki Ducati Red Asiatic Lily Bulbs, 2 Pack
Red, trumpet-shaped flowers and a stated height of up to three feet give this two-bulb Asiatic set a clear role: a smaller, colorful planting rather than a tall, fragrant backdrop. The listing supplies useful growing guidance, including zones 3–9, full sun to partial shade, and planting depth, which makes it easier to plan than the Stargazer four-pack, whose care details are missing. It is also a more compact alternative to Votaniki’s Oriental Lily Mix, which reaches 4–5 feet and offers several colors but needs more room. The tradeoff is quantity: two bulbs provide less coverage, and the listed growing conditions call for well-drained soil and moderate watering. Choose these for a defined red accent, not a broad bed or fragrant cut-flower display.
Pros:- Red, trumpet-shaped blooms create a distinct color accent.
- Listed mature height of up to three feet suits beds and containers without the scale of taller Oriental lilies.
- Growing details include hardiness zones 3–9 and planting depth of 6–8 inches.
- The blooms are described as attractive to hummingbirds and butterflies.
Cons:- Two bulbs offer less planting coverage than the four-bulb Stargazer set.
- Requires well-drained soil and moderate watering.
- Bulbs may need mulch protection in freezing conditions.
Best for: Gardeners who want a small outdoor planting of red lilies and value stated guidance on height, hardiness, spacing, and planting depth.
Not ideal for: Buyers filling a large border, seeking fragrant blooms, or unable to provide well-drained soil and moderate watering.
- Plant type:Asiatic lily
- Pack size:2 bulbs
- Color:Red
- Expected plant height:Up to 3 feet
- Expected blooming period:Summer
- Sunlight exposure:Full sun to partial shade
- USDA hardiness zone:3 to 9
- Planting depth and spacing:6–8 inches deep; 4–6 inches apart
- Soil and moisture:Well-drained soil; moderate watering
Our verdict“Pick Ducati Red for a compact, well-documented red lily planting; choose the Oriental Lily Mix instead for taller stems, fragrance, and multiple colors.”
Votaniki Oriental Lily Mix Bulbs, 3 Pack
Tall stems, fragrant blooms, and several listed colors make this three-bulb Oriental mix the strongest choice here for a dramatic mid-summer display. At 4–5 feet, it can anchor the back of a border, while its described long vase life also makes it a better cut-flower candidate than the more compact Ducati Red Asiatic lilies. The mix offers more color variety than the Stargazer four-pack, though that listing names one variety and includes an extra bulb. This Votaniki option trades quantity for clearer growing guidance: it specifies zones 3–9, planting depth and spacing, and a soil pH range. Its height needs room and may not suit exposed or compact sites, and the soil must drain well despite moderate watering needs. Choose it for a tall, scented focal planting, not a low-maintenance small-space display.
Pros:- Large, fragrant blooms are listed in pink, red, white, and yellow.
- Stems reaching 4–5 feet can form a strong backdrop in borders and beds.
- The listing provides hardiness, soil pH, planting depth, and spacing guidance.
- Described long vase life makes the blooms useful for cut arrangements.
Cons:- Three bulbs provide less quantity than the four-bulb Stargazer pack.
- Tall stems need more vertical space than the three-foot Ducati Red lilies.
- Requires well-draining soil and moderate watering without waterlogging.
Best for: Gardeners with a sunny-to-partly-shaded border who want tall, fragrant, multicolored lilies for both garden impact and cut arrangements.
Not ideal for: Small-space gardeners who need compact plants, or growers with poorly draining soil or no room for 4–5-foot stems.
- Plant type:Oriental lilies
- Pack size:3 bulbs
- Bloom colors:Pink, red, white, and yellow
- Plant height:4–5 feet
- Expected blooming period:Summer
- Sunlight exposure:Full sun to partial shade
- USDA hardiness zone:3 to 9
- Planting depth and spacing:6–8 inches deep; 6–8 inches apart
- Soil and moisture:Well-draining soil; pH 6.0–7.0; moderate watering
Our verdict“Choose this mix for a tall, fragrant, multicolor display with detailed planting guidance; choose Ducati Red for a smaller planting with a more compact stated height.”

How We Picked
I compared the 13 listings by first separating plantable dormant bulbs from artificial flowers, since only the former can produce living garden blooms. Among bulb listings, I weighed stated pack size, lily type, color specificity or mix, and how clearly the product suits a particular planting goal. A larger count can cover more ground, while a small named-color pack can be a better fit for a deliberate accent or a cautious first planting.
The ranking gives priority to useful planting potential and clear buyer fit, not simply to the biggest pack or boldest color claim. Mixed assortments rank well for broad coverage but lose ground when color control matters; small packs rank higher for distinctive, targeted choices than for filling a large bed. Artificial options are included because they appear in the supplied lineup, but they rank as décor rather than as candidates for the best garden bulbs. The product details provided do not specify growing zones, bulb size, bloom timing, or care instructions, so I avoid treating those as verified advantages.
| lily bulb | Plant type |
|---|---|
| Giant Hybrid Lily Empoli Artif | — |
| Giant Pretty Lady Tree Lily Bu | Lily |
| CZ Grain Lollipop Asiatic Lily | Asiatic lily |
| Easy to Grow ‘Dark Secret’ Asi | Asiatic lily hybrid |
| 3 Large Pink Stargazer Lily Bu | Oriental lily |
| Blacklist Asiatic Lily Bulbs | — |
| All Summer Blooms Asiatic Lily | — |
| BRECK’S All Summer Lily Mixtur | — |
| Easy to Grow Oriental Lily Mix | — |
| Asiatic Lily Rapid Yellow Arti | — |
| Oriental Stargazer Lily Bulbs | Oriental lily |
| Votaniki Ducati Red Asiatic Li | Asiatic lily |
| Votaniki Oriental Lily Mix Bul | Oriental lilies |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Lily Bulbs
Before choosing, match the listing to the job you want it to do: grow flowers in soil, make a coordinated color display, or add lily-shaped décor without gardening. These broader checks can prevent common mismatches that pack counts and flower photos alone may not reveal.
Check That the Listing Is for Living Bulbs
Start by checking whether the item is a dormant bulb or an artificial flower; the word “lily” alone does not tell you. Artificial Empoli and Rapid Yellow flowers can decorate a room or event, but they will not root, grow, or bloom outdoors. For garden planting, look for explicit bulb wording and read the listing details before ordering. If the product description is unclear about whether it is living plant material, do not infer that from the flower image. This simple check matters more than color or pack size because the two product types serve entirely different purposes.
Choose Between Asiatic and Oriental Types
The lineup includes both Asiatic and Oriental lilies, along with products described simply as lily mixes. That distinction can help narrow a display, but a type name by itself does not provide all the growing information a gardener may need. Check the seller’s full growing details for climate suitability, expected height, and bloom timing before pairing varieties. Avoid assuming that every lily in a mixed pack will look or behave alike; the available listing names do not confirm the exact varieties inside each assortment. If consistency matters, a named type or color-focused option may be easier to plan around than a broad mix.
Match Pack Size to the Space You Can Plant
Pack counts range from two bulbs to 25, so decide how much planting space you actually have before choosing. Larger assortments can help cover a bed, but they may be excessive for containers or a small border. A small pack is a lower-commitment way to try a variety, though it may leave gaps if you want a continuous display. Count usable planting positions, then check the seller’s recommended spacing rather than dividing the pack across a bed by guesswork. The stated count is a useful comparison point, not a promise of a particular visual effect.
Decide How Much Color Control You Want
A named-color selection such as Ducati Red or Dark Secret better suits a deliberate color scheme, while mixed packs trade precision for variety. If matching a border or coordinating with existing plants matters, favor a clearly named color and verify what the listing says will ship. A mix can create a more varied look, but the product title may not identify every color or its proportions. Do not assume a “mixture” will produce an even split of shades. For a formal arrangement, buying a single color family may be more predictable than relying on an unspecified assortment.
Read Beyond the Flower Photo
Photos can show a mature bloom without revealing bulb size, planting depth, or delivery condition. Before buying, check whether the seller identifies the bulbs as dormant and provides handling and planting directions. Confirm the shipping window and storage advice so you know how to care for bulbs if they arrive before planting conditions are suitable. Product names in this lineup do not consistently state these details, so compare the full listing rather than relying on the headline. Clear instructions are especially useful if you are new to bulbs or ordering a variety you have not grown before.
Pay for the Right Kind of Variety
A larger pack is useful only if you want more planting coverage; it is not automatically the better choice for every garden. Pay for a mix when range and quantity matter more than precise color placement, and choose a smaller named selection when a specific shade is the point. A premium-looking flower image does not confirm larger bulbs or better growing performance, so look for those details in the listing before assigning value. Beginners may prefer a modest pack with clear planting guidance over a large assortment that is harder to place. For décor rather than gardening, artificial flowers may fit the purpose better, but they should not be compared as living bulbs.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which listing should I choose if I want the most bulbs for a garden bed?
BRECK’S All Summer Lily Mixture lists 25 dormant bulbs, the largest stated count in this lineup, so it is the clearest choice for a broader planting. Its mixed nature means you may have less control over the final color arrangement than with a named-color pack. Check the seller’s spacing guidance and your available bed area before deciding that the full count suits your space. If you want a substantial planting focused on Oriental lilies instead, the Easy to Grow Oriental Lily Mix lists 12 bulbs. Neither count alone confirms bulb size or how full the display will look.
Are the Giant Hybrid Lily Empoli and Rapid Yellow products bulbs I can plant?
No. Both listings describe artificial flowers, so they are decorative items rather than living bulbs. They will not root, grow, or produce flowers in a garden, and bulb-growing advice does not apply to them. Choose one only if you want a lily-like display without planting or seasonal care. For a living planting, select a listing that explicitly identifies bulbs, such as the dormant BRECK’S mixture or one of the named Asiatic and Oriental bulb options. Read the full product details if you are uncertain about the item type.
Should I choose an Asiatic or an Oriental lily listing?
Choose based on the type of display you want and the growing information available for your location, rather than assuming one type is universally better. This roundup offers several Asiatic selections and mixes, plus Oriental options including Stargazer and Oriental mixes. The listing names identify type, but they do not provide enough detail here to confirm height, hardiness, or exact bloom timing. Check the seller’s care directions and compare them with your garden conditions before ordering. If those details are missing, a more clearly documented product may be the safer choice.
Is a mixed-color pack a better choice than a named-color pack?
A mixed pack makes sense when you want variety or broad planting coverage and are comfortable with less control over the final arrangement. A named-color selection is a better match for a coordinated border or a specific accent, such as a deep burgundy or red planting. Product titles may not state the colors or quantities inside every mix, so check the full listing if composition matters. The larger 25-count mixture prioritizes quantity, while smaller named selections prioritize a more focused color choice. Neither format is automatically better; the right one depends on how precisely you want to plan the display.
What should a first-time bulb buyer prioritize in this lineup?
A first-time buyer should prioritize clear planting and storage instructions, a manageable pack size, and a variety suited to the available space. The supplied product names do not establish which seller provides the clearest directions, so inspect the full listing before choosing. A small pack can limit the consequences of a poor fit, while a large mix may require more planting room and more decisions about placement. Also confirm that the item is a living bulb, since two products here are artificial flowers. If key details such as planting depth or climate guidance are absent, consider another listing with more complete instructions.
Conclusion
For the strongest all-around planting option, I recommend BRECK’S All Summer Lily Mixture: its 25 dormant bulbs give it the most stated coverage, though the mixed colors are less suited to tightly controlled designs. For best value by planting quantity, it is also the leading pick, while the 12-count Easy to Grow Oriental Lily Mix is a more focused alternative for buyers who want an Oriental assortment. For a premium-feeling, distinctive focal color, consider Blacklist Asiatic Lily for its nearly black burgundy description, while recognizing that the three-bulb pack is small. Beginners should start with a manageable living-bulb pack and prioritize clear seller instructions; the product names alone do not identify a universally easiest variety. For a specific color, compare Ducati Red, Dark Secret, Stargazer, and Lollipop by the look you want. If you need lily décor without gardening, choose an artificial option—but not as a substitute for bulbs.
















