For most people shopping for pens for journaling, I recommend the Sharpie S-Gel 0.7mm 4-Pack because its smooth gel format, controlled line, and modest pack size suit everyday writing without demanding a large initial purchase. The Pilot G2 Premium is the stronger choice for refillability and finer handwriting, while the iBayam 18-Color Fineliner Set gives color coders and illustrated-journal fans far more range. The main choice is between the bold glide of gel ink, the precision of a fine tip, and the visual organization offered by multiple colors. Paper thickness, drying time, grip comfort, and replacement cost can matter more than decorative barrel design. Continue reading for my full breakdown of which option fits each journaling style and which compromises come with it.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Sharpie S-Gel takes Best Overall because its 0.7mm line offers the most balanced mix of smooth writing and everyday control; the larger S-Gel packs mainly improve value or barrel variety rather than performance.
- Pilot G2 is the refillable standout, making it a better long-term choice than disposable multipacks for journalers who write daily and prefer replacing ink instead of the full pen.
- iBayam provides the broadest color system with 18 shades and a 0.38mm tip, while Paper Mate InkJoy and Ddaowanx Colored Gel Pens favor a bolder gel look with fewer colors.
- Fine tips separate the detail-focused picks: Ddaowanx Quick Dry, Taja, and Ddaowanx Colored use 0.5mm points, while iBayam goes narrower for compact lettering and intricate trackers.
- Paper Mate Flair is the clearest gel alternative, offering a marker-like line that suits headers and emphasis but may be less forgiving than gel on thin or absorbent journal paper.
| pens for journaling | Ink color | Pen type | Grip | Point size |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sharpie S-Gel Retractable Gel | Black | Retractable gel pen | Contoured rubber | 0.7mm |
| Sharpie S-Gel Gel Pens | Black | — | — | — |
| Sharpie S-Gel Gel Pens | Black | Gel pen | Rubber grip | 0.7mm |
| Pilot G2 Premium Refillable Re | Black | Retractable gel pen | Contoured rubber | 0.7mm |
| Ddaowanx Gel Pens | Black | Gel pen | — | — |
| Paper Mate Flair Felt Tip Pens | — | Felt tip | — | 0.7mm medium |
| Sooez Gel Pens | Black | Gel | Soft grip | 0.7mm medium |
| Drawdart Smooth Writing Pens | Black | Gel | Soft touch | — |
| Paper Mate InkJoy Gel Pens | — | Gel | Ergonomic comfort grip | 0.7mm medium |
| UIXJODO Colorful Gel Pens | — | Gel | — | — |
| Ddaowanx Colored Gel Pens | Multicolor vintage shades | — | Soft silicone | — |
| Sharpie S-Gel Gel Pens | Black | — | Contoured rubber | Medium, 0.7mm |
| Taja Gel Pens | Black | — | Cushioned | — |
| iBayam Fineliner Pen Set | — | — | — | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Sharpie S-Gel Retractable Gel Pen, Medium Point, Black Ink, 4-Pack
I rank the Sharpie S-Gel 4-Pack first because it offers the strongest balance of clean ink performance, writing comfort, and sensible quantity for everyday journaling. Its quick-drying, smear-resistant black ink keeps facing pages tidy, while the contoured grip suits longer entries better than a slim, unpadded barrel. Compared with the Ddaowanx 0.5mm Gel Pens, its 0.7mm point produces a bolder line that feels better suited to open layouts and expressive handwriting. The Pilot G2 adds refillability, but this smaller pack asks for less commitment from buyers still choosing a favorite pen. I would skip it for tiny handwriting or densely ruled journals: the medium point uses more page space, and the black-only format cannot support color-coded spreads.
Pros:- Quick-drying ink helps keep facing journal pages clean
- No-smear, no-bleed technology supports tidy entries
- Contoured rubber grip is suited to longer writing sessions
- Four-pack provides backups without requiring a large purchase
Cons:- The 0.7mm line can crowd narrow ruling and compact layouts
- Black ink only prevents color coding
- Disposable format lacks the refillability of the Pilot G2
Best for: Daily journal writers who want bold, clean black lines, a cushioned grip, and a manageable starter pack
Not ideal for: Writers with tiny handwriting or color-coded journals, because the 0.7mm point is relatively broad and every pen uses black ink
- Pen type:Retractable gel pen
- Point type:Medium
- Point size:0.7mm
- Ink color:Black
- Pack size:4 pens
- Ink technology:No smear, no bleed
- Drying characteristic:Quick-drying
- Grip:Contoured rubber
Our verdict“I recommend this as the most balanced choice for journal writers who favor bold black ink and comfortable daily writing.”
Sharpie S-Gel Gel Pens, Medium Point (0.7mm), Assorted Fashion Barrels, Black Ink, 12 Count
The Sharpie S-Gel Fashion Barrel 12-Pack earns its place by pairing dependable black ink with a more decorative exterior, making it the better Sharpie choice for a coordinated journal desk or gift bundle. Writing performance remains practical: the 0.7mm line is bold, the ink resists smearing and bleeding, and the contoured grip supports lengthy entries. Against the Sharpie S-Gel Black Barrel 12-Pack, the main advantage is visual variety rather than a different mark on the page. It ranks below the four-pack because twelve identical black-ink pens are excessive for an occasional writer. I would choose it for frequent journaling and shared stationery supplies, but not for artistic spreads; fashion barrels do not replace multicolor ink, and the single medium point offers no line-width flexibility.
Pros:- Fashion barrels add visual variety to a journaling setup
- Twelve-count pack suits frequent writing or shared supplies
- No-smear, no-bleed ink promotes cleaner pages
- Contoured rubber grip supports extended entries
Cons:- Barrel colors do not provide different ink colors
- Twelve pens may be more than a casual journal writer needs
- Only one 0.7mm line width is included
Best for: Frequent journal writers or stationery gift buyers who want a large black-ink supply with more decorative barrels
Not ideal for: Occasional writers and color-coding enthusiasts, since twelve medium-point pens may be excessive and all produce black lines
- Writing instrument:Gel pen
- Point type:Medium
- Line size:0.7mm
- Ink color:Black
- Pack size:12 pens
- Barrel style:Assorted fashion designs
- Grip type:Contoured rubber
- Item weight:3.52 ounces
- Ink technology:No smear, no bleed
Our verdict“I would pick this set for high-frequency black-ink journaling when decorative barrels matter as much as having plenty of backups.”
Sharpie S-Gel Gel Pens, Black Barrel, Medium Point (0.7mm), 12 Count
I place the Sharpie S-Gel Black Barrel 12-Pack ahead of more decorative sets for writers who fill pages quickly and want every replacement to feel identical. The uniform barrels, bold 0.7mm output, and quick-drying gel ink make this a practical supply for morning pages, study journals, and sustained note-heavy routines. Compared with the Sharpie S-Gel Fashion Barrel 12-Pack, it sacrifices visual variety but keeps a restrained appearance that fits work and personal journals alike. The four-pack remains the smarter general recommendation because it creates less surplus. This version makes sense only when twelve pens will genuinely be used. Its other compromises are familiar: black ink rules out color coding, and the medium line can overwhelm compact handwriting or closely spaced planners.
Pros:- Large twelve-count supply suits high-volume writing
- Uniform black barrels provide a restrained, consistent appearance
- Quick-drying gel ink reduces stray smears
- Rubber grip adds comfort during long entries
Cons:- Large pack creates unnecessary surplus for occasional writers
- Medium 0.7mm point can feel broad on narrow-ruled pages
- No ink-color variety for trackers or coded notes
Best for: Prolific journal writers who fill pages daily and want a uniform twelve-pen reserve for consistent black-ink entries
Not ideal for: Casual writers, compact planners, and decorative journalers who need finer lines or multiple ink colors
- Pen type:Gel pen
- Point type:Medium
- Point size:0.7mm
- Ink color:Black
- Barrel color:Black
- Pack size:12 pens
- Drying characteristic:Quick-drying
- Ink performance:No smear, no bleed
- Grip:Rubber grip
Our verdict“I recommend this pack to prolific black-ink journalers who value a consistent pen supply more than decorative variety.”
Pilot G2 Premium Refillable Retractable Gel Pens, Fine Point, Black Ink, 12 Count
The Pilot G2 12-Pack stands apart as the refillable choice, a meaningful advantage for someone who journals often and prefers replacing ink rather than whole pens. Its 0.7mm point balances readable detail with a substantial black line, while fade-resistant ink suits entries meant to be kept. Compared with the Sharpie S-Gel Black Barrel 12-Pack, the G2 offers a longer-term ownership model and broader use for writing, drawing, and detailed notes. It does not take the top position because refills cost extra and add another item to source. The line is also broader than the Ddaowanx 0.5mm pen, making it less suited to tiny lettering. I favor it for sustained journaling habits, but black-only ink limits decorative planning and the large pack requires a firm commitment.
Pros:- Refillable construction reduces repeated barrel disposal
- Fade-resistant black ink is suited to journals kept long term
- Quick-drying flow helps reduce smudged entries
- Contoured rubber grip supports extended writing
Cons:- Replacement refills are an additional purchase
- Black ink alone cannot support color-coded layouts
- Twelve-count pack is a sizable commitment
Best for: Long-term journal keepers who write frequently, want fade-resistant black ink, and prefer refillable pens
Not ideal for: Occasional writers or buyers seeking a complete multicolor system, since the pack is large, black-only, and refills cost extra
- Pen type:Retractable gel pen
- Point designation:Fine
- Point size:0.7mm
- Ink color:Black
- Pack size:12 pens
- Refillable:Yes
- Ink properties:Quick-drying and fade-resistant
- Grip:Contoured rubber
- Mechanism:Retractable
Our verdict“I would choose the Pilot G2 for a lasting journaling routine where refillability and archival readability outweigh the added refill cost.”
Ddaowanx Gel Pens, 6 Pcs 0.5mm Retractable Quick Dry Black Ink Pens
The Ddaowanx 0.5mm Gel Pen Set is my pick for fitting more words into small journals, narrow ruling, and tightly structured trackers. Its finer line uses less page space than the 0.7mm Sharpie S-Gel pens, while the quick-drying black ink helps keep dense layouts legible. Six pens also strike a middle ground between Sharpie’s four-pack and Pilot G2’s twelve-count supply. The minimalist retractable design and carrying clip make this set convenient for writers who move between a desk, commute, and café. Fine output brings tradeoffs: it lacks the visual weight of the Sharpie S-Gel, and writers who press firmly may prefer a broader point. I would also skip it for colorful spreads because every pen writes in black. Its best role is precise everyday journaling, not decorative illustration.
Pros:- Fine 0.5mm tip fits compact handwriting and narrow ruling
- Quick-drying ink helps preserve dense, tidy layouts
- Six-pack balances backup supply with portability
- Retractable body and clip suit journaling away from a desk
Cons:- Fine line has less visual weight than 0.7mm alternatives
- Black-only set offers no color-coding options
- Writers who favor broad, fluid strokes may find the tip too restrained
Best for: Writers with compact handwriting who use narrow-ruled notebooks, small trackers, or dense journal layouts
Not ideal for: Writers who prefer bold, expressive lines or multicolor spreads, because the 0.5mm output is restrained and black-only
- Pen type:Gel pen
- Tip size:0.5mm
- Ink color:Black
- Quantity:6 pens
- Mechanism:Retractable
- Drying characteristic:Quick-drying
- Design:Minimalist
- Carry feature:Pocket clip
Our verdict“I recommend this set for compact, precise journal entries when a finer line matters more than boldness or color variety.”
Paper Mate Flair Felt Tip Pens, Medium Point (0.7mm), 12 Count
I rank the Paper Mate Flair as the strongest felt-tip choice for journalers who want writing to feel closer to illustration. Its 12 assorted colors and bold 0.7mm lines give headings, trackers, and decorative accents more presence than the finer iBayam Fineliner set. The guarded tip also resists fraying, which helps the line remain consistent through frequent lettering sessions. Compared with Paper Mate InkJoy Gel pens, the Flair produces a more marker-like page and offers fade-resistant ink, but it is less suited to tiny handwriting or densely packed entries. Although the ink is designed to resist bleeding, paper thickness still affects results. I would choose this set for expressive layouts, while writers seeking a smooth ball-tip feel or very precise detail should favor a gel pen or fineliner.
Pros:- Twelve vivid colors support expressive layouts and color-coded sections
- Smear-proof, fade-resistant ink helps entries remain clean and legible
- Ink is designed to resist bleeding through paper
- Point guard helps prevent the felt tip from fraying
Cons:- The 0.7mm felt tip is too broad for very small writing and dense page layouts
- Felt-tip feedback will not appeal to writers who prefer the glide of gel ink
- Assorted colors may look different from their packaging or online images
Best for: Creative journalers who use bold headings, color coding, trackers, and decorative lettering
Not ideal for: Writers with tiny handwriting or thin, highly absorbent journal paper, since the 0.7mm felt tip creates a relatively broad, saturated line
- Pen Type:Felt tip
- Point Size:0.7mm medium
- Pen Count:12
- Ink Colors:Assorted
- Ink Properties:Smear-proof and fade-resistant
- Paper Performance:Designed not to bleed through
- Tip Protection:Point guard
Our verdict“I recommend the Paper Mate Flair for colorful, expressive journal pages, but not for compact writing or gel-pen devotees.”
Sooez Gel Pens, 8 Pack, 0.7mm Black Ink, Smooth Writing, Retractable, Gift Set
The Sooez Gel Pens earn this role by pairing practical black ink with a more playful, gift-ready appearance. Their retractable bodies and soft grips suit long diary entries, while quick-drying 0.7mm gel ink reduces the chance of smearing a finished line. Compared with the Drawdart 12-pack, this set offers fewer pens and lacks the same stated high-capacity advantage, so it is not my value choice for heavy daily writing. It makes a stronger case as an attractive desk set or small present. The black-only ink also limits color coding, unlike Paper Mate InkJoy Gel pens, and the medium line cannot match the UIXJODO set for compact annotations. I would pick Sooez for comfortable everyday prose, provided decorative color and refillability are lower priorities.
Pros:- Quick-drying gel ink helps limit smears during everyday writing
- Soft grip supports longer journal entries
- Retractable mechanism avoids loose caps
- Stylish bodies and playful detailing make the set suitable for gifting
Cons:- Black ink offers no built-in color-coding options
- Eight pens provide less bulk value than the 12-count Drawdart set
- Plastic construction may feel less substantial than the styling suggests
Best for: Journalers seeking a comfortable, presentable black-ink set for daily entries or a small stationery gift
Not ideal for: Color coders, fine-print writers, and high-volume users who need more pens, multiple ink colors, or refillable bodies
- Pen Type:Gel
- Quantity:8 pens
- Ink Color:Black
- Point Size:0.7mm medium
- Ink Performance:Smooth and quick-drying
- Mechanism:Retractable
- Grip:Soft grip
Our verdict“I would choose Sooez for comfortable black-ink journaling in a giftable package, not for maximum quantity or creative color work.”
Drawdart Smooth Writing Pens, 12 Pcs No Bleed & Smear, Black Ink Fine Point (0.7mm), Retractable Gel Pens
I place the Drawdart 12-pack ahead of Sooez for journalers who write often and care more about supply than presentation. Each retractable pen carries a stated 30% more ink than standard, making this lineup better suited to morning pages, study journals, and other high-volume routines. The quick-drying black ink is also a sensible match for left-handed writers who frequently drag a hand across fresh lines. Compared with the Pilot G2, though, Drawdart lacks a stated refill option, so the larger initial capacity does not provide the same long-term reuse. Its 0.7mm point is called fine in the product data but still writes broader than the 0.5mm UIXJODO pens. I favor it for dependable, skip-free prose; artists, color coders, and buyers wanting sturdier bodies should choose another option.
Pros:- Twelve-pen supply suits frequent and high-volume journaling
- Quick-drying, smudge-resistant ink is friendly to left-handed writing
- Stated 30% greater ink capacity extends use between replacements
- Soft-touch grip and retractable body support convenient daily use
Cons:- Black ink cannot support multicolor organization without another set
- No refill option is stated, unlike the refillable Pilot G2
- Plastic bodies may be less durable than heavier reusable pens
Best for: High-volume journalers and left-handed writers who want a large supply of quick-drying black gel pens
Not ideal for: Sustainability-minded buyers or visual journalers who need refillable bodies, multiple colors, or broad decorative strokes
- Pen Type:Gel
- Number of Pens:12
- Ink Color:Black
- Tip Size:0.7mm
- Ink Capacity:30% more than standard
- Drying Performance:Quick-drying and smudge-resistant
- Mechanism:Retractable
- Grip:Soft touch
- Clip:Metal
Our verdict“I recommend Drawdart for frequent black-ink journaling when capacity and fast drying matter more than refillability or color.”
Paper Mate InkJoy Gel Pens, Assorted, Medium Point (0.7mm), 14 Count
The Paper Mate InkJoy Gel set takes my color-focused gel role because its 14 pens provide a broader palette than the six-color UIXJODO pack while retaining a smooth ball-tip feel. That combination works well for separating journal themes, marking habits, and adding bright headings without switching to felt tips. Its fast-drying, smear-resistant ink also gives it a cleaner everyday-writing profile than slower-drying decorative gels. Against Paper Mate Flair, InkJoy feels smoother and better suited to longer passages, though Flair creates bolder, more marker-like accents. The limitation is precision: every InkJoy here uses a 0.7mm point, so crowded planners and tiny annotations are better served by UIXJODO or the 0.38mm iBayam Fineliners. With no stated refill option and unspecified individual colors, I see this as a versatile creative set rather than a tightly controlled palette.
Pros:- Fourteen assorted pens provide the widest gel color selection in this batch
- Fast-drying ink helps reduce smears on journal pages
- Smooth gel flow works for both decorative elements and longer entries
- Ergonomic grip adds comfort during extended writing sessions
Cons:- The 0.7mm point can crowd small grids and compact handwriting
- Individual colors are not specified, making the exact palette uncertain
- No refill option is mentioned, increasing replacement waste
Best for: Visual journalers who want many gel-ink colors for trackers, headings, themed entries, and longer handwritten passages
Not ideal for: Minimalist writers, tiny-grid journal users, or buyers who need specified shades and refillable pens
- Pen Type:Gel
- Quantity:14 pens
- Ink Colors:Assorted
- Point Size:0.7mm medium
- Ink Performance:Fast-drying and smear-resistant
- Writing Character:Smooth and vibrant
- Grip:Ergonomic comfort grip
Our verdict“I favor InkJoy for journalers who want a broad, smooth-writing gel palette and can accept medium lines and disposable bodies.”
UIXJODO Colorful Gel Pens, 6 Pack, Fine Point, Smooth Writing, Gold Vintage Design
I give the UIXJODO Colorful Gel Pens a style-led role because they combine six ink colors with gold vintage bodies and a genuinely useful 0.5mm fine point. That narrower line leaves more room in dated journals and small habit-tracker boxes than the 0.7mm Paper Mate InkJoy pens. The steel ball clip also makes the pens easy to attach to a journal cover or pouch. Style comes with compromises: six colors offer far less range than InkJoy’s 14, while the iBayam Fineliners provide finer 0.38mm control and three times as many shades. Gel ink may also smear if a page is closed too quickly. I would select UIXJODO when appearance, portability, and tidy colored writing carry equal weight, but not when palette breadth or the fastest drying performance drives the purchase.
Pros:- Fine 0.5mm tips fit compact entries and small tracker boxes
- Six ink colors support basic visual organization
- Smooth gel flow suits neat handwriting and detailed page accents
- Gold vintage styling and steel ball clips create a distinctive gift-ready set
Cons:- Six colors provide much less variety than InkJoy or iBayam sets
- Gel ink can smear when touched or covered before it dries
- Decorative bodies may appeal less to buyers who prefer understated work pens
Best for: Style-conscious journalers who want fine colored lines for compact layouts and pens attractive enough to give as a gift
Not ideal for: Artists and intensive color coders who need a broad palette, ultra-fine tips, or firmly stated quick-drying performance
- Pen Type:Gel
- Number of Pens:6
- Ink Colors:Six assorted colors
- Tip Size:0.5mm fine
- Writing Performance:Smooth ink flow
- Body Design:Gold vintage styling
- Clip:Steel ball clip
- Ink Description:Imported ink
Our verdict“I recommend UIXJODO for neat, colorful journaling with decorative flair, provided six shades are enough.”
Ddaowanx Colored Gel Pens, 0.5mm Fine Point, 6 Pack
I rank Ddaowanx Colored Gel Pens as the best small color set because six vintage shades add structure and personality to journal pages without the bulk of a large art kit. Compared with the iBayam Fineliner Pen Set, its retractable bodies and soft grips are easier to carry and better suited to extended writing, while the quick-drying 0.5mm ink supports compact headers, annotations, and color coding with less smudge risk. The tradeoff is range: iBayam supplies 18 colors and a finer point for intricate layouts, so Ddaowanx feels more like a writing set than an illustration set. I also place it below black-ink workhorses for long entries because color fading may become apparent with heavy use, and buyers cannot choose a broader or finer tip. This is the portable creative middle ground in the lineup.
Pros:- Six vintage ink colors support compact color-coding systems
- Quick-drying ink reduces smudges during rapid note-taking
- Retractable format travels without loose caps
- Soft grip supports longer journal entries
Cons:- Six-color range is limited beside larger fineliner sets
- Only one 0.5mm tip width is included
- Colors may fade with heavy use over time
Best for: Journalers who want a compact, retractable set for color-coded notes, headers, and portable creative writing
Not ideal for: Artists who need a broad color palette or writers who prefer multiple tip widths for lettering and illustration
- Quantity:6 pens
- Ink color:Multicolor vintage shades
- Line size:0.5mm
- Point type:Fine
- Closure:Retractable
- Grip:Soft silicone
- Ink base:Water-based
- Hand orientation:Left
Our verdict“Choose this set for portable, color-coded journaling with gel-pen comfort, but pick iBayam if palette size matters more.”
Sharpie S-Gel Gel Pens, Green Barrel, Black Ink, 0.7mm, 4 Count
I place Sharpie S-Gel 0.7mm in the bold daily-writing slot: its vivid black line is easier to scan on dense journal pages than the finer marks from Taja Gel Pens or Pilot G2 Fine Point. The listed no-smear, no-bleed design pairs with a contoured rubber grip, making this a strong fit for long morning pages, work logs, and readers who press firmly. Compared with the 12-count Sharpie S-Gel options in the roundup, though, this four-pen pack offers less stock; the green barrel is the main distinguishing detail, not a different writing system. A 0.7mm tip also consumes more page space than Taja’s 0.5mm point, and black-only ink limits visual coding. Because the ink is not water resistant, I would keep it away from watercolor spreads and journals carried in wet conditions.
Pros:- Bold 0.7mm black line remains easy to scan
- Listed no-smear and no-bleed technology supports cleaner pages
- Contoured rubber grip suits extended writing
- Retractable mechanism avoids cap management
Cons:- Four-count pack provides less stock than the 12-count Sharpie options
- Black ink offers no color-coding variety
- Non-water-resistant ink is poorly matched to wet media
Best for: Daily journal writers who favor bold, readable black lines and a cushioned grip for long prose entries
Not ideal for: Compact writers, color coders, and mixed-media journalers who need fine lines or water-resistant ink
- Quantity:4 pens
- Ink color:Black
- Point size:Medium, 0.7mm
- Closure:Retractable
- Grip:Contoured rubber
- Barrel color:Green
- Water resistance:Not water resistant
- Body shape:Round
Our verdict“This Sharpie set makes sense for bold everyday prose, while fine-tip or mixed-media journalers should choose another option.”
Taja Gel Pens, Black Ink, 0.5mm Fine Point, 6 Pack
I give Taja Gel Pens the quiet-journaling role because the silent click mechanism reduces small distractions during meetings, shared study sessions, or late-night entries. Its quick-drying 0.5mm black ink is more precise than the Sharpie S-Gel 0.7mm line, leaving more room for compact handwriting and narrow planner boxes, while the cushioned grip favors longer passages. Unlike Ddaowanx Colored Gel Pens, however, the pastel barrels do not signal matching ink colors; all six write in black, so this set adds desk style rather than page variety. I would also rank it behind Pilot G2 for buyers focused on long-term economy, since no refill system is stated. Fine-point fans get a controlled everyday writer, but people who want broad, expressive lettering may find the line too restrained. The six-piece supply suits rotation across bags and notebooks.
Pros:- Silent click mechanism suits quiet rooms and meetings
- Fine 0.5mm point fits compact handwriting and planner boxes
- Quick-drying black ink helps keep facing pages clean
- Cushioned grip supports longer writing sessions
Cons:- Pastel barrels contain black ink rather than coordinating colors
- Fine line lacks the visual weight needed for bold lettering
- No refill option is stated
Best for: Fine-print journalers who write in shared or quiet spaces and want several comfortable black-ink pens
Not ideal for: Decorative journalers seeking matching pastel inks, broad lettering, or a documented refill system
- Quantity:6 pens
- Ink color:Black
- Tip size:0.5mm
- Point type:Fine
- Barrel design:Pastel colors
- Closure:Retractable
- Grip:Cushioned
- Click mechanism:Silent
Our verdict“Pick Taja for discreet, precise black-ink journaling, not for colorful spreads or broad expressive marks.”
iBayam Fineliner Pen Set, 18 Colors, 0.38mm Fine Point
I rank iBayam Fineliner Pen Set as the strongest color-coding choice here because 18 shades support layered trackers, themed spreads, and detailed doodles without forcing repeated colors. Its 0.38mm point is finer than the 0.5mm Ddaowanx Colored Gel Pens and the 0.7mm Paper Mate Flair, giving small handwriting and intricate borders cleaner separation. The supplied case also keeps a large palette together. That precision comes with a cost: the tip is less satisfying for broad lettering, heavy fills, or writers who prefer a plush gel feel. Ddaowanx is easier for quick one-handed use thanks to its retractable format, while iBayam functions more like a hybrid writing-and-drawing kit. The water-based, minimal-bleed-through ink suits many journal layouts, but ink durability may vary and paper still affects show-through. I see this as the best creative system, not the best plain prose pen.
Pros:- Eighteen colors provide the broadest creative range in this batch
- Fine 0.38mm tips support intricate borders and compact writing
- Water-based ink is designed for minimal bleed-through
- Included storage case keeps the full palette organized
Cons:- Very fine tips are inefficient for broad lettering and filled areas
- Fineliner feel is firmer than a cushioned gel-pen stroke
- Ink durability may vary across colors and paper types
Best for: Bullet journalers and visual note-takers who need many colors for trackers, detailed layouts, and small annotations
Not ideal for: Prose-focused writers who prefer retractable gel pens, broad lettering, or thicker cushioned lines
- Quantity:18 pens
- Ink colors:18 assorted colors
- Tip size:0.38mm
- Ink type:Water-based
- Bleed-through:Minimal
- Included storage:Plastic case and transparent vinyl bag
- Dimensions:6.6 x 6.2 x 0.6 inches
- Weight:3.84 ounces
Our verdict“Choose iBayam for detailed, color-heavy journal layouts, but select Ddaowanx or Sharpie for simpler everyday writing.”
How We Picked
I evaluated these pens through the needs of a journaler rather than treating every writing instrument as interchangeable. My main criteria were line control, drying and bleed claims, writing format, tip size, color usefulness, pack composition, refillability, and likely cost per pen. I gave greater weight to features that affect a full page of handwriting, including whether a point supports small lettering, whether a retractable body is convenient during frequent stops, and whether the ink format suits thin journal paper.
The order begins with options offering the broadest everyday appeal, followed by value packs and products built around narrower needs such as quick drying, decorative presentation, color coding, or illustration. I ranked the Sharpie S-Gel 4-Pack above its larger siblings because it provides the same core writing format in a lower-commitment package; the 12-count versions make more sense for frequent writers or shared supplies. Decorative barrels received less weight than ink and tip performance, while specialist sets earned credit only when their color range or precision created a clear journaling benefit.
| pens for journaling | Pen type | Ink color |
|---|---|---|
| Sharpie S-Gel Retractable Gel | Retractable gel pen | Black |
| Sharpie S-Gel Gel Pens | — | Black |
| Sharpie S-Gel Gel Pens | Gel pen | Black |
| Pilot G2 Premium Refillable Re | Retractable gel pen | Black |
| Ddaowanx Gel Pens | Gel pen | Black |
| Paper Mate Flair Felt Tip Pens | Felt tip | — |
| Sooez Gel Pens | Gel | Black |
| Drawdart Smooth Writing Pens | Gel | Black |
| Paper Mate InkJoy Gel Pens | Gel | — |
| UIXJODO Colorful Gel Pens | Gel | — |
| Ddaowanx Colored Gel Pens | — | Multicolor vintage shades |
| Sharpie S-Gel Gel Pens | — | Black |
| Taja Gel Pens | — | Black |
| iBayam Fineliner Pen Set | — | — |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Pens For Journaling
I would choose a journaling pen by matching its ink, point, and pack size to the pages I actually plan to create. A pen suited to long reflective entries may feel clumsy in a compact habit tracker, while a precise fineliner can feel slow across several pages of prose. The factors below explain how paper compatibility, writing style, and long-term cost shape that choice.
Match the Tip Size to Your Page Layout
A 0.7mm point creates a confident, easily read line and works well for standard-size handwriting, but it can crowd narrow grids or small dated boxes. A 0.5mm tip gives compact writers more room without becoming as delicate as a fineliner. At 0.38mm, a pen favors detailed trackers, annotations, and tiny lettering, though filling full pages may take longer and feel less fluid. I would avoid choosing the narrowest tip solely because it looks precise in product photos. Writers who press firmly may find very fine points scratchier or more prone to catching on textured paper. For mixed layouts, a medium gel pen for entries paired with a fine pen for labels is often more useful than forcing one point size into every task.
Choose Ink Around Paper and Drying Time
Gel ink usually provides a darker, smoother line, yet the extra ink on the page can require more drying time. That matters for left-handed writers, rapid note-taking, and anyone who closes a journal immediately after writing. Water-based fineliner and felt-tip ink can produce crisp color, but absorbent or thin paper may show more ghosting and feathering. I would check the journal’s paper weight and surface before blaming the pen for every mark visible on the reverse side. Coated paper can slow drying, while rough paper may make fine tips feel less smooth. A small test on a back page remains the safest way to judge an unfamiliar pen-and-paper pairing.
Decide Whether Color Has a Job
A large color set earns its space when each shade supports a repeatable system, such as separating habits, moods, appointments, and reflections. Without that plan, 18 colors can become clutter rather than an advantage. A six-color gel pack offers a simpler middle ground for journalers who want contrast without spending time choosing among similar shades. I favor black ink for long entries because it keeps pages visually calm and makes replacement easier. Colored ink is more useful for headings, keys, charts, and drawings than for every paragraph. Buyers who mainly write prose will usually get more value from a dependable black multipack than from a broad palette.
Compare Pack Price With Long-Term Value
The cheapest pack is not always the lowest-cost choice if several colors remain unused or the pen bodies must be discarded when empty. A refillable pen can make sense for daily journaling, provided replacement cartridges are easy to obtain and priced reasonably. Large multipacks lower the cost per pen but require confidence that the tip and ink already suit your handwriting. I see a four- or six-pen pack as a safer starting point for buyers switching ink types. Twelve-count black packs serve consistent writers better because every pen has the same practical role. Decorative gift sets may justify a higher price for presentation and barrel design, but they rarely improve the written page by the same margin.
Prioritize Comfort for Long Entries
Short planner notes can hide grip problems that become obvious during several pages of reflective writing. A wider barrel or cushioned grip may reduce pinching, while a slim decorative body may suit brief captions better than long sessions. Retractable designs are convenient when a journal entry involves frequent pauses, and they remove the risk of misplacing a cap. Capped felt tips and fineliners demand more care because leaving them exposed may shorten their useful life. I would place writing comfort above barrel appearance when journaling is a daily habit. Buyers who alternate between prose, trackers, and sketches may still prefer two specialized pens over one compromise design.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Gel Pens or Fineliners Better for Journaling?
I would choose gel pens for long-form writing because their darker ink and smoother glide usually suit full pages of prose. Fineliners are better for detail, including compact trackers, diagrams, small labels, and controlled illustrations. Gel can take longer to dry, while water-based fineliner ink may show through thin or absorbent pages. Journalers who combine reflection with planning may benefit from using both formats rather than seeking one pen for every page element. In this lineup, Sharpie S-Gel and Pilot G2 represent the prose-focused side, while iBayam serves the precision-and-color role.
What Tip Size Works Best for Small Handwriting?
For small handwriting, I would start with a 0.5mm point because it preserves letter spacing without feeling overly delicate. A 0.38mm fineliner provides even more room in narrow grids, but its finer line can look lighter and feel less fluid during long entries. Standard 0.7mm gel pens suit average handwriting and create stronger headings, though closely packed letters may merge. The Ddaowanx and Taja 0.5mm options offer a middle path, while iBayam’s 0.38mm tip favors the smallest layouts. Point size should follow actual letter height and paper ruling rather than a general preference for fine-looking lines.
Will These Pens Bleed Through Journal Paper?
Bleed-through depends on both the ink and the journal paper, so no pen choice can answer that question by itself. Thin, absorbent pages are more likely to show feathering or marks on the reverse, particularly with saturated felt-tip ink. Gel often sits closer to the paper’s surface, though heavy pressure and repeated strokes can still create visible ghosting. I would test a new pen on the final page and check it after the ink has dried. Among these formats, fine gel pens and the minimal-bleed iBayam set are the more promising starting points for delicate paper, while Paper Mate Flair deserves extra caution.
Which Pens Make the Most Sense for Left-Handed Journalers?
I would prioritize quick-drying ink because the writing hand can pass directly over fresh lines. Fine points also lay down less ink than broad, saturated tips, which may shorten the drying window. The Ddaowanx Quick Dry 0.5mm set has the clearest left-handed focus in this group, while medium gel pens may need a slower writing pace on coated paper. Paper angle and hand position still affect smearing, so a product label cannot predict every result. A back-page test comparing smear resistance after a few seconds is more informative than judging smoothness alone.
Should a Beginner Buy a Large Multipack or a Small Set?
I recommend a small four- or six-pen set when a beginner has not settled on a preferred tip size or ink type. It limits wasted pens if the line feels too broad, the grip becomes uncomfortable, or the ink clashes with the journal paper. A 12-count black pack offers better unit value only when the buyer already likes that writing format. Color sets can be appealing, but too many shades may complicate a new journaling routine. The Sharpie S-Gel 4-Pack is the lowest-commitment all-purpose starting point here, while Pilot G2 adds refillability for beginners ready to maintain one pen system.
Conclusion
For the broadest mix of smooth writing, control, and approachable pack size, my Best Overall choice is the Sharpie S-Gel 0.7mm 4-Pack. High-volume writers seeking Best Value should move to the Sharpie S-Gel Black Barrel 12 Count, while buyers who value an elevated vintage presentation can choose the UIXJODO Colorful Gel Pens as the premium-style pick. I would steer beginners toward the Pilot G2 Premium for its familiar retractable format and refillable design, although the smaller Sharpie pack involves less commitment. For specific needs, Ddaowanx Quick Dry suits left-handed and fine-point writers, Paper Mate Flair works best for bold headers, and iBayam is the strongest choice for color coding, tiny lettering, and journal illustration. Buyers wanting colorful gel ink rather than fineliner precision should favor Paper Mate InkJoy, while Taja and Ddaowanx Colored serve those who want a narrower 0.5mm line.
